A fire pit turns a backyard into a gathering spot. Guests gravitate to it. Conversations happen around it. Marshmallows get roasted. But the difference between a good fire pit and a frustrating one comes down to how easy it is to start, how much smoke it produces, where you sit relative to the heat, and what you have to clean up the next morning.

We tested 6 fire pits across different backyard sizes and use cases. Wood-burning, propane, smokeless, and portable — each one has a situation where it makes sense and situations where it does not.

What to Look For in an Outdoor Fire Pit

Fuel Type: Wood vs. Propane vs. Natural Gas

Wood-burning fire pits are the traditional choice. Wood is cheap or free if you have a supply, the fire is authentic, and you get the full campfire experience. The downsides are smoke, ash cleanup, sparks, and the time it takes to build and maintain a fire.

Propane fire pits start instantly with a push-button ignition, produce no smoke, and leave no ash. You control the flame height with a dial. The trade-off is fuel cost (a 20-pound propane tank lasts 8-12 hours at medium flame) and the missing “campfire” feel — no crackle, no smell of woodsmoke.

Natural gas fire pits connect to your home gas line. They share the convenience of propane with the benefit of never running out of fuel. Installation requires a gas line connection and usually a professional, raising the upfront cost significantly.

Smokeless Technology

Double-wall fire pits (like Solo Stove and Tiki) use secondary combustion: air is drawn from below, heated between the walls, and injected through holes near the top of the fire pit. This burns the smoke particles that would otherwise drift into your face. The result is 80-90% less smoke than a traditional open fire pit. The trade-off is that smokeless pits burn through wood faster because they are more efficient — a bundle of firewood that lasts 2 hours in a standard pit lasts 1 to 1.5 hours in a smokeless design.

Heat Output and Direction

Open fire pits radiate heat in all directions — you feel warm from any angle but only within a certain radius. Propane fire pits often direct heat upward or have a reflective bowl that sends heat outward. Smokeless pits concentrate heat upward due to the airflow design, which means you need to stand closer to feel the warmth. A fire pit is only as useful as the distance you can comfortably sit from it on a cool night.

Size and Portability

A 36-inch fire pit dominates a patio but does not move. A 15-inch portable pit fits in a car trunk and goes to the beach or campsite. Your available storage space and typical use case dictate the size. Most first-time buyers underestimate how large a fire pit is — a 30-inch bowl takes up a 4-foot diameter circle when you include the safety clearance around it.

Materials and Durability

Steel fire pits rust within 2-3 seasons without a protective coating or weather cover. Stainless steel resists rust indefinitely but costs more. Cast iron holds heat longest but is heavy and cracks if stored wet. Corten (weathering) steel forms a rust patina that protects the metal underneath — it looks rusty but stays structurally sound for decades. Most mid-range fire pits use painted carbon steel, which needs a cover and occasional touch-up paint.


Top 6 Outdoor Fire Pits Reviewed

1. Solo Stove Bonfire 2.0 — Best Smokeless Fire Pit

Check Price on Amazon →

The Solo Stove Bonfire 2.0 redefined the backyard fire pit category by eliminating the biggest annoyance of wood fires: smoke. The double-wall stainless steel design pulls air from below, heats it between the walls, and sends it through a ring of holes at the top, creating secondary combustion that burns off smoke particles. The result is a fire with almost no visible smoke once it gets going (the first 5-10 minutes while the fire establishes do produce some smoke).

The 19.5-inch diameter is large enough for a decent fire but small enough to move around. The stainless steel construction is rust-proof and the included stand and carry bag make it genuinely portable. The pellet adapter (sold separately) lets you burn wood pellets instead of logs, which burn cleaner and produce less ash. The trade-off is that the efficient design burns through wood faster than an open fire pit — keep extra fuel on hand.

Material: 304 stainless steel | Diameter: 19.5" | Fuel: Wood | Weight: 21 lbs | Smokeless: Yes (double-wall secondary combustion)

Pros:

  • Minimal smoke — genuinely smokeless after the first few minutes
  • Stainless steel — no rust, no maintenance
  • Burns efficiently with hot, clean flame
  • Portable with included carry bag
  • Pellet adapter available for alternative fuel
  • Compact footprint fits small patios and balconies
  • Easy ash cleanup with removable bottom plate

Cons:

  • Burns through wood faster than open fire pits
  • 19.5-inch diameter limits fire size for larger gatherings
  • No spark screen included (sold separately)
  • Wind can disrupt the secondary combustion airflow
  • Heat radiates primarily upward — less warmth at seating level
  • Price is premium for the size

Verdict: The default choice for anyone who wants a wood fire without the smoke. The Bonfire 2.0 is well-built, portable, and delivers on its core promise. Buy the spark screen and pellet adapter to get the most out of it.


2. Outland Living 810 Firebowl — Best Propane Fire Pit

Check Price on Amazon →

The Outland Living Firebowl 810 is a complete propane fire pit package. The 20-inch diameter bowl, 50,000 BTU burner, push-button ignition, and 10-foot hose with regulator all come in the box. Add a 20-pound propane tank and you have a fire in 30 seconds with no wood, no smoke, no ash, and no sparks.

The burner is rated at 50,000 BTUs — enough to produce a flame 12-15 inches tall at full output. The included lava rock set distributes heat outward and hides the burner element. The push-button ignition works consistently (replace the AAA battery seasonally). The steel bowl has a painted finish that holds up well under a weather cover but can rust if left exposed in rain.

Material: Steel with painted finish | Diameter: 20" | Fuel: Propane | BTU: 50,000 | Weight: 32 lbs

Pros:

  • Instant ignition — push button, adjust flame, done in 30 seconds
  • No smoke, no ash, no sparks — clean operation
  • 50,000 BTUs produces a large, adjustable flame
  • Complete package — includes hose, regulator, and lava rock
  • Push-button electronic ignition works reliably
  • Flame adjusts from low glow to 15-inch flame
  • Cleanup is non-existent — close the valve and you are done

Cons:

  • Propane tank adds cost and runs out (8-12 hours per tank)
  • No campfire crackle or woodsmoke smell
  • Lava rock can spall (pop) when first heated — normal, but startling
  • Painted steel can rust if left uncovered
  • 32 pounds plus propane tank is not easily portable
  • 50,000 BTUs can be too much for small patios — you feel the heat at 15 feet

Verdict: The best propane fire pit for people who want instant fire with no cleanup. The 50,000 BTU output is generous, and the package includes everything except the propane tank. No ash, no smoke, no sparks — just turn a knob and sit down.


3. Tiki Brand 28-Inch Fire Pit — Best Wood-Burning Fire Pit

Check Price on Amazon →

The Tiki Brand 28-inch fire pit is a traditional wood-burning design with modern materials. The 28-inch diameter steel bowl is large enough for substantial logs and the included cooking grate turns it into a grill for hot dogs, burgers, or a cast iron skillet. The spark screen keeps embers contained and doubles as a cooking surface support.

The steel construction with high-temperature paint holds up well for 3-4 seasons before needing touch-up. The included poker and log grate are functional. The 28-inch size is the sweet spot for most patios — large enough for 4-6 people to gather around without dominating the space. Assembly is minimal — attach the legs with the included hardware in under 10 minutes.

Material: Steel with high-temp paint | Diameter: 28" | Fuel: Wood | Weight: 35 lbs | Includes: Cooking grate, spark screen, poker

Pros:

  • Large 28-inch bowl accommodates full-size logs
  • Includes cooking grate — grill hot dogs and burgers over the fire
  • Spark screen with lift handle is easy to open one-handed
  • Affordably priced for the size and included accessories
  • Simple 10-minute assembly
  • Log grate keeps wood off the bowl bottom for better airflow
  • Good heat output for groups of 4-6 people

Cons:

  • Produces standard wood fire smoke — you sit upwind or deal with it
  • Steel bowl rusts within 2-3 seasons without a cover
  • High-temp paint can discolor from intense fires
  • No ash collection system — ash spills when moving or cleaning
  • Cooking grate is thin — warps over direct flame after a few uses
  • Legs are short — you sit on low chairs or the ground

Verdict: The best traditional wood-burning fire pit for the price. Large enough for real logs, includes a cooking grate, and the spark screen provides peace of mind. Cover it when not in use and expect 3-4 years from the finish.


4. Breeo X Series 24 — Best Premium Smokeless Fire Pit

Check Price on Amazon →

Breeo builds smokeless fire pits that compete with Solo Stove at a higher price point with better heat output. The X Series 24 uses a double-wall 304 stainless steel design with a wider diameter (24 inches) and a larger fire bowl than the Solo Stove Bonfire. The result is a smokeless fire that radiates more heat and can accommodate larger logs without cutting them down to fit.

The signature feature of the Breeo is the “flame effect” — the secondary combustion ring creates 8-12 inch flames that curl inward, creating a hypnotic fire pattern. The stainless steel construction is rust-proof, and the included cooking grate and outpost (a swing-arm for hanging a kettle) convert it into an outdoor cooking station. The weight (38 pounds) makes it less portable than the Solo Stove but more stable.

Material: 304 stainless steel | Diameter: 24" | Fuel: Wood | Weight: 38 lbs | Smokeless: Yes (double-wall secondary combustion)

Pros:

  • 24-inch diameter fits full-size logs without cutting
  • Smokeless — secondary combustion burns away smoke
  • Wider bowl radiates more heat than smaller smokeless pits
  • Cooking grate and outpost accessories make it a versatile cooker
  • Stainless steel — no rust, no maintenance
  • Flame effect is visually impressive
  • Built in the USA with lifetime warranty

Cons:

  • Expensive — premium price for the size and brand
  • Heavy at 38 pounds — not for frequent moving
  • Burns through wood faster than non-smokeless pits
  • Requires dry, seasoned wood for optimal smokeless performance
  • Accessories (outpost, kettle) sold separately
  • 24 inches takes up significant patio space

Verdict: The best premium smokeless fire pit for people who want a larger fire and built-in cooking capability. The Breeo X Series 24 burns bigger logs, radiates more heat, and doubles as a cook station. Expensive but built to last a lifetime.


5. Yaheetech 26-Inch Portable Fire Pit — Best Budget Fire Pit

Check Price on Amazon →

The Yaheetech 26-inch fire pit is the budget option that does not feel cheap. The steel bowl is 26 inches across — generous for the price — with a painted matte black finish. It includes a spark screen, poker, and log grate in the box. Assembly takes 15 minutes with the included Allen wrench.

The fire pit produces a standard wood fire with normal smoke levels. The painted finish is adequate for 2-3 seasons with a cover. The legs are three-bolt attachments that can wobble if not tightened fully. For around $60, this is the cheapest way to get a full-size wood-burning fire pit on your patio. It is not built to last a decade, but it introduces the fire pit experience at a nearly disposable price point.

Material: Steel with matte paint | Diameter: 26" | Fuel: Wood | Weight: 18 lbs | Includes: Spark screen, poker, log grate

Pros:

  • Very affordable — the lowest price for this size
  • 26-inch diameter accommodates full-size logs
  • Includes spark screen, poker, and log grate
  • Lightweight at 18 pounds — moves easily
  • Simple assembly with included tools
  • Matte black finish looks good out of the box
  • Large enough for groups of 4-6

Cons:

  • Painted steel rusts within 2 seasons without a cover
  • Legs can wobble if not tightened properly
  • No ash cleanup system — ash spills during removal
  • Spark screen mesh is thin — can warp from high heat
  • Paint on bowl discolors after first few fires
  • Not for heavy-duty or frequent use

Verdict: The best budget fire pit for occasional backyard use. For the price of a dinner out, you get a full-size wood-burning fire pit with all the accessories. Manage expectations on longevity and cover it after each use.


6. UCO Flat Pack Portable Fire Pit — Best Portable Fire Pit

Check Price on Amazon →

UCO’s Flat Pack fire pit is a backpacker’s solution that works equally well for tailgating. The 304 stainless steel fire pan folds flat into a 16-inch by 12-inch by 1-inch package that fits in a duffel bag or trunk. The four fold-out legs support the pan 8 inches off the ground, and the included heat shield prevents scorching the ground underneath.

The 15-inch by 11-inch fire pan is smaller than any other pit in this comparison — you are burning small sticks and branches, not full-size logs. But for beach trips, campsites, and tailgate parking lots where a permanent fire pit is not an option, the UCO Flat Pack is the most packable fire pit on the market. The stainless steel construction will not rust, and the silicone foot pads protect the paint on your car’s trunk.

Material: 304 stainless steel | Dimensions: 15" x 11" x 6" | Fuel: Wood | Weight: 3.2 lbs | Folded Size: 16" x 12" x 1"

Pros:

  • Folds flat to 1-inch thick — fits in any bag or trunk
  • Stainless steel is rust-proof and easy to clean
  • Heat shield protects ground underneath
  • Silicone foot pads protect vehicle surfaces
  • Sets up in 30 seconds with no tools
  • Lightweight at 3.2 pounds
  • Burns small wood, twigs, and fire-starting pellets

Cons:

  • Small fire size — 15-inch pan limits fuel to kindling and small sticks
  • Not for cooking (no cooking grate or support)
  • No smoke control — produces standard wood smoke
  • No spark screen included
  • Legs are short — fire is close to the ground
  • Not for permanent installation — strictly portable use

Verdict: The fire pit to take when you cannot have a fire pit. Beach days, campgrounds, parking lots before the game — the UCO Flat Pack fits in a bag and sets up in seconds. Small fire but big enough for the experience.


Comparison Table

ModelFuelDiameterMaterialSmokelessWeightPortabilityBest ForPrice
Solo Stove Bonfire 2.0Wood19.5"304 SSYes21 lbsCarry bag includedSmokeless wood fires$$$
Outland Living Firebowl 810Propane20"Painted steelN/A (no smoke)32 lbsModerateInstant fire, no cleanup$$$
Tiki Brand 28-InchWood28"Painted steelNo35 lbsLowTraditional fires, cooking$$
Breeo X Series 24Wood24"304 SSYes38 lbsLow (heavy)Premium smokeless, cooking$$$$$
Yaheetech 26-InchWood26"Painted steelNo18 lbsHigh (light)Budget backyard fires$
UCO Flat PackWood15" x 11"304 SSNo3.2 lbsVery high (folds flat)Beach, camping, travel$$

FAQ

Are smokeless fire pits really smokeless?

The short answer is “mostly.” Double-wall fire pits like Solo Stove and Breeo produce 80-90% less smoke than an open fire pit, but they still produce some smoke during the first 5-10 minutes while the fire establishes itself. Once the secondary combustion kicks in, visible smoke drops to near zero. Wind can disrupt the airflow and increase smoke. Wet or green wood produces significant smoke regardless of the fire pit design. Use dry, seasoned wood with less than 20% moisture content for the best results.

Is propane or wood better for a fire pit?

Propane is better for convenience, cleanliness, and control. Wood is better for atmosphere, heat output, and cost. If you want to sit outside on a Tuesday evening after dinner and have a fire for an hour, propane wins. If you want a 4-hour backyard gathering with friends that feels like a campfire, wood wins. Many people start with a propane pit for the convenience and buy a wood pit later for the weekends.

How far should a fire pit be from a house?

Minimum 10 feet from any structure, including your house, fence, shed, and deck railing. Check your local fire codes — some municipalities require 15-25 feet. The fire pit should also sit on a non-combustible surface (stone, brick, concrete, gravel). Do not place a fire pit directly on wood decking, grass, or dry leaves. A spark screen is recommended for wood-burning pits at any distance.

What is the best way to put out a fire pit?

For wood fires: let the fire burn down to ash, then spread the embers with a poker and let them cool. Pour water slowly over the ashes while stirring — avoid dumping a bucket of water that creates a steam explosion and ash cloud. For propane fires: turn the gas valve off at the source (the tank, not the burner dial). Wait 30 seconds, then turn the burner dial to off to clear the line. Never leave a fire pit unattended while it is burning.

How do I clean a fire pit?

For wood pits: remove cold ash and dispose of it. Ash is alkaline and good for garden soil in small amounts. Wipe the interior with a dry cloth. Do not use water inside a steel bowl — moisture accelerates rust. Cover the pit when not in use. For propane pits: the lava rock or fire glass lasts indefinitely — rinse it with a hose once a year to remove dust and spider webs. Wipe the burner cover dry before lighting.

Can I cook on a fire pit?

Yes, but only on fire pits designed for cooking or with a cooking grate accessory. The Solo Stove Bonfire and Breeo X Series have cooking grates. The Tiki Brand 28-inch includes a cooking grate. Never cook directly over a propane fire pit’s burner — the lava rock can contain mineral fibers that are not food-safe. Use a dedicated grill grate that sits above the lava rock level.


The Bottom Line

The Solo Stove Bonfire 2.0 is the fire pit most people should buy. It delivers on the smokeless promise, is portable enough to move around the yard, and the stainless steel construction will not rust.

For instant fire with no cleanup, the Outland Living Firebowl 810 is the propane choice. Push-button start and zero ash make it the easiest fire pit to use on a regular weeknight.

The Tiki Brand 28-Inch is the traditional wood burner that does it all — large fire, cooking grate, spark screen, all at a reasonable price. Cover it and expect 3-4 good years.

If budget is the constraint, the Yaheetech 26-Inch gets you a full-size fire pit for the price of a round of drinks. Manage expectations on longevity and it works fine for occasional use.

The Breeo X Series 24 is for people who want the best. Larger fire than the Solo Stove, built-in cooking capability, lifetime warranty. Expensive but you only buy it once.

And the UCO Flat Pack is for taking the fire with you. Beach trips, camping, tailgating — folds flat to an inch thick and weighs nothing.

A fire pit is the cheapest way to make your backyard feel like a destination. Even a basic one with a bundle of wood and a few chairs changes how you use your outdoor space.

Disclosure: We may earn an affiliate commission if you purchase through links on this page — at no extra cost to you.