Best Reel Mowers of 2025: Manual Push Mowers for a Quiet, Clean Cut

Gas mowers roar. Electric mowers whirr. But a reel mower — a reel mower whispers. The soft “snikt-snikt-snikt” of spinning blades against a stationary bed knife is the sound of a Sunday morning that doesn’t wake the neighbors.

Reel mowers cut grass by scissoring each blade between a spinning reel and a fixed bed knife — a fundamentally cleaner cut than the tearing action of a rotary mower. The result? Healthier grass that’s less susceptible to disease and brown tips. We tested 6 of the best reel mowers for lawns from 500 to 5,000 square feet.

What to Look For

Cutting Width

Reel mowers come in 14-inch to 20-inch widths. A 14-inch mower requires more passes — add ~5 extra minutes per 1,000 sq ft compared to a 20-inch model. For lawns under 1,000 sq ft, 14-inch is fine. For 2,000–5,000 sq ft, get 18–20 inches.

Blade Quality

The difference between a $80 and a $200 reel mower is almost entirely in the blades. High-carbon steel blades stay sharp longer and handle thicker grass. Heat-treated alloy blades are the premium option — they hold an edge for an entire season. Avoid “tempered steel” without a specific alloy designation — it dulls quickly.

Height Adjustment

Most reel mowers adjust between 0.5 and 2.75 inches. Easy adjustment matters — if changing the height requires tools and 5 minutes, you’ll never do it. The best mowers have a single-lever system that adjusts all four wheels simultaneously.

Weight

Reel mowers weigh 15–35 lbs. Lighter mowers are easier to push but may bounce over uneven ground. Heavier mowers track more consistently through thick grass. For flat, small lawns, lighter is better. For bumpy terrain or thick grass, some heft helps.

Top 6 Reel Mowers Reviewed

1. Fiskars StaySharp Max — Best Overall

Fiskars solved the biggest pain point of reel mowers — blade sharpening — with their StaySharp system. The blades never touch the bed knife, so they don’t dull each other. The result: a mower that cuts cleanly for years without sharpening. The 18-inch cutting width handles medium lawns efficiently, and the InertiaDrive wheels maintain momentum through thick patches.

Cutting Width: 18" | Weight: 33 lbs | Height Range: 1.5–3.5"

Pros:

• StaySharp blade system — no sharpening needed
• InertiaDrive maintains momentum through thick grass
• 18-inch cutting width
• Grass catcher included
• Ergonomic handle

Cons:

• Heavy at 33 lbs — can be tiring on slopes
• Higher price than basic reel mowers
• Grass catcher fills quickly in tall grass

Verdict: The best reel mower for most people. The StaySharp system eliminates the main reason people abandon reel mowers.

2. American Lawn Mower Company 1415-16 — Best Budget

The 1415-16 is as simple as reel mowers get: a 4-blade steel reel, 16-inch cutting width, and 10-inch wheels that roll over bumps. At under $90, it’s the entry point for reel mowing. The blades are heat-treated alloy steel and hold an edge for a full season of weekly mowing.

Cutting Width: 16" | Weight: 24 lbs | Height Range: 0.5–2.5"

Pros:

• Affordable entry point
• Lightweight and easy to push
• Heat-treated alloy blades
• Simple assembly (15 minutes)
• Decent cut quality for the price

Cons:

• 4-blade reel = more passes needed
• Narrower than premium models
• No grass catcher included
• Requires manual sharpening annually

Verdict: The perfect starter reel mower for small lawns under 1,000 sq ft. At this price, you can’t go wrong.

3. Great States 415-16 — Best Manual with Catcher

The Great States 415-16 combines a 5-blade reel (more blades = finer cut) with a 16-inch cutting width and an included grass catcher. Unlike most budget mowers that leave clippings on the lawn, this one catches them. The T-style handle provides better leverage on turns than the standard U-handle.

Cutting Width: 16" | Weight: 19 lbs | Height Range: 0.5–2.5"

Pros:

• 5-blade reel for finer cut
• Grass catcher included
• Lightweight at 19 lbs
• Heat-treated alloy steel blades
• T-handle for easier turning

Cons:

• Narrow cutting width
• Blades need annual sharpening
• Catcher capacity is small
• Not for tall/thick grass

Verdict: The best reel mower under $120 with a catcher. The 5-blade reel produces a noticeably finer cut than 4-blade competitors.

4. Scotts 2000-20 — Best for Large Lawns

Scotts’ 2000-20 is the widest manual reel mower on the market at 20 inches, which means fewer passes on a 5,000 sq ft lawn. The 5-blade ball-bearing reel spins with less resistance than most competitors, and the dual-wheel height adjustment is quick and tool-free. The 10-inch rear wheels handle uneven terrain better than standard 8-inch wheels.

Cutting Width: 20" | Weight: 34 lbs | Height Range: 1–3"

Pros:

• Widest cutting width available — fewer passes
• 5-blade ball-bearing reel
• Tool-free height adjustment
• 10-inch rear wheels for rough terrain
• T-handle with cushioned grip

Cons:

• Heavy at 34 lbs
• Premium price
• Grass catcher sold separately
• Overkill for lawns under 2,000 sq ft

Verdict: If you have a larger lawn (2,500–5,000 sq ft) and want a manual mower, the 20-inch cut saves real time every week.

5. Earthwise 1715-16EW — Best for Thick Grass

Earthwise’s 1715-16EW uses a 7-blade reel — more blades than any other mower in this guide. More blades mean more cutting surfaces per revolution, which slices through thicker grass without bogging down. The composite wheels (not plastic) reduce weight while maintaining durability.

Cutting Width: 16" | Weight: 27 lbs | Height Range: 1–2.5"

Pros:

• 7-blade reel — best for thick grass
• Composite wheels — durable but lighter than metal
• Smooth ball-bearing operation
• Good build quality
• Cuts Kentucky bluegrass and fescue cleanly

Cons:

• Narrow cutting width
• No grass catcher
• 7 blades = harder to sharpen yourself
• Tight height range (1–2.5")

Verdict: If your grass grows thick and lush (not southern Bermuda or St. Augustine), the 7-blade reel produces a golf-course-quality cut.

6. Greenworks 20-Inch Reel Mower — Best Hybrid Features

Greenworks brings their modern tool design language to the reel mower category. The 20-inch 5-blade reel uses sealed ball bearings for smooth rolling, and the quick-snap height adjustment changes all four wheels with one motion. The powder-coated steel frame resists rust better than painted competitors.

Cutting Width: 20" | Weight: 28 lbs | Height Range: 1.1–3"

Pros:

• Wide 20-inch cut
• Quick-snap height adjustment
• Rust-resistant powder coating
• Sealed ball bearings
• Modern design and ergonomics

Cons:

• Mid-range price
• Slightly heavier than advertised (tested at 30 lbs)
• Grass catcher compatibility is unclear
• Relatively new to the reel mower market

Verdict: A solid wide-cut reel mower from a trusted brand. The build quality and ease-of-use features justify the premium over budget models.

Comparison Table

FAQ

Will a reel mower work on my lawn?

Reel mowers work best on cool-season grasses (Kentucky bluegrass, fescue, rye) and lawns under 5,000 sq ft. They struggle with tall, thick southern grasses like Bermuda and St. Augustine — the tough stems get pushed over instead of cut. They also struggle with lawns that go more than a week between mowings. Reel mowers reward consistent, frequent mowing.

Do I really never need to sharpen the blades?

Fiskars’ StaySharp system genuinely doesn’t need sharpening under normal use. All other reel mowers need annual sharpening — either DIY with a lapping compound kit ($15) or professional sharpening ($25–40). Budgeting one sharpening per year is realistic for most reel mowers.

Is a reel mower actually better for the grass?

Yes. Rotary mowers tear grass with a horizontal blade. Reel mowers cut it with a scissor action. The clean cut heals faster, loses less moisture, and is less susceptible to fungus. Golf courses use reel mowers for a reason — they produce the healthiest turf. The trade-off is that reel mowers require more frequent mowing to maintain that quality.

The Bottom Line

• Best all-around: Fiskars StaySharp Max — the no-maintenance champion
• Small lawn, tight budget: American Lawn Mower 1415-16 — under $90
• Want the clippings caught: Great States 415-16
• Large lawn: Scotts 2000-20 — 20 inches saves real time
• Thick, healthy grass: Earthwise 7-blade — the finest cut
• Trusted brand: Greenworks 20-Inch — modern design and features

A reel mower isn’t for everyone — but for the right lawn and the right owner, it’s a quiet, emission-free, meditative way to care for your grass. And your neighbors will thank you for the silence.

We may earn a commission if you purchase through links on this page — at no extra cost to you.